Every hypothetical question, by theme
Updated
Hypothetical Questions · tableparty.io/hypothetical-questions
Funny hypothetical questions
- What would you name a boat if you had to live on it for a year?
- If your fridge could send you texts, what would its first message say?
- If you had to swap your handshake for a dance move, which one would you pick?
- If your pet could talk for one day, what would you be most worried it would say?
- What would you do if every door you opened made a loud trumpet sound?
- If you became a new flavour of crisps, what would you taste like?
- If you were a ghost, which room in your home would you haunt, and how?
- If you had to speak in a pirate voice at work for a week, how long before someone said something?
- If you could add one silly rule to your home that everyone had to follow, what would it be?
- If you could only talk in mime for a day, what would be hardest to get across?
- If your life had a narrator, would you want them calm, dramatic or sarcastic, and why?
- Suppose a goose followed you everywhere for a month. How would you explain it to people?
- If your sneezes changed the weather, what would you do with that?
- Suppose you became famous for something completely ordinary. What would it be?
- What would you do if everyone could hear your thoughts out loud for one hour, starting now?
Hypothetical questions about superpowers and magic
Every power comes with a cost. Hold people to it.
- If you could fly but only at walking pace, where would you go first?
- If you got one superpower that only worked on Tuesdays, which would you choose?
- If you could grow any plant instantly by humming, what would you grow?
- If you could be invisible only while holding your breath, what would you use it for?
- Suppose you could talk to animals but they all complained constantly. Would you still want to?
- If you could fix any broken object by touching it, once a day, what would you fix first?
- If you could change one rule of physics for a day, which would you change?
- If every wish you made came true exactly one week late, what would you wish for?
- If you could borrow one skill from someone you know for a week, which skill would you take?
- If you could read minds but never switch it off, would you keep the power?
- If you could speak every language but forgot your own, would you take the deal?
- If you could pause time but still aged while it was paused, how often would you use it?
- If a genie gave you three wishes, each with a twist you couldn’t predict, would you still make them?
- If you could see one minute into the future, how would it change your days?
- If you could live forever but had to move to a new town every ten years, would you?
Hypothetical questions about time travel and history
- If you could visit any decade for a weekend, which would you pick?
- What would you pack if you were going back 500 years for a month?
- If a time traveller from 1900 stayed with you, what would you show them first?
- If you could watch any moment in history happen in person, which would you choose?
- If you met your ten-year-old self, what would you tell them?
- If you met yourself from twenty years in the future, what would you ask first?
- If you could relive one ordinary day from your childhood, which would it be?
- If you could take one modern invention back to the Middle Ages, which would change the most?
- If you could overhear one conversation from history, which would you choose?
- If you lived in another era for a year, how would you earn your keep?
- Suppose you could time travel once and never come back. Would you go forward or back?
- If you could undo one embarrassing moment but lose the story with it, would you?
- If you could ask one question of someone living a thousand years from now, what would it be?
- If people in the future could watch everything you do today, would you change anything?
- If you could stay one age forever, which age would you pick and why?
Hypothetical questions about money and luck
Prizes, windfalls and strange strokes of luck.
- If you found a ten-pound note on the street, what would you spend it on?
- If you won a year of free meals at one kind of restaurant, which would you choose?
- Suppose every vending machine gave you two of everything. What would you stock up on?
- If you got a pound every time you said one word, which word would you pick?
- If you had perfect luck for one day, how would you use it?
- If you found a lucky charm that really worked but looked ridiculous, would you wear it every day?
- If you were handed a free plane ticket that had to be used tomorrow, would you go?
- If you could open any kind of shop with no chance of it failing, what would you sell?
- What would you buy first if you won a big prize but had to spend it all in one day?
- If you inherited a castle that cost a fortune to heat, would you keep it?
- If you were given a million but had to spend it on other people, where would it go?
- If someone paid you to stay in one room for a month, how much would it take?
- If you won a fortune but couldn’t tell anyone, how long could you keep the secret?
- If your bills were covered for life starting tomorrow, how would you spend your days?
- If money stopped existing tomorrow, what would you miss and what would you be glad to lose?
Hypothetical questions about everyday dilemmas
Small situations with no clean way out.
- What would you do if a waiter brought you the wrong dish but it looked better than yours?
- If a shop gave you too much change, would you go back, and how far would you walk?
- If you were invited to two parties on the same night, how would you choose?
- If someone took your lunch from the office fridge, would you investigate or let it go?
- If you realised halfway through a film that you’d seen it before, would you say so?
- If a stranger’s dog followed you home, how long would you wait before naming it?
- If your neighbour’s music kept you up every night, how would you handle it?
- If you got the last seat on a train and someone who looked exhausted got on, would you stand up?
- Suppose a friend lent you a book you hated. What would you say when they asked about it?
- If you found a wallet with cash in it, what would you do first?
- What would you do if you found out you’d been saying a coworker’s name wrong for a year?
- Suppose you open a present you don’t like while the giver is watching. What do you say?
- If a friend’s cooking was awful and they asked for honest feedback, what would you say?
- If you accidentally sent a message to the very person it was about, what would you do next?
- If you found out a surprise party was planned for you, would you let anyone know you knew?
Hypothetical questions about survival and the end of the world
Islands, zombies and bunkers, kept light.
- If you were stranded on an island, which three things would you want with you?
- If zombies appeared tomorrow, which room in your home would you defend?
- If the power went out for a month, what would you miss first?
- If you had ten minutes to leave your home for good, what would you grab?
- If you had to live in a bunker for a year, what hobby would you take up?
- Who at this table would you want on your team if you had to survive a week in the woods, and why?
- If you could only eat food you grew yourself for a year, what would you plant?
- If you were the last person awake on a spaceship, how would you pass the time?
- If you had to survive in the wild for a week, which skill would you wish you had?
- Suppose the internet vanished forever. How would your daily life change?
- If aliens landed and asked to see one thing that sums up humans, what would you show them?
- If the world ended and you helped rebuild a town, what job would you take?
- If you had to pick five skills to restart civilisation, which five would you choose?
- If you knew the world would end in a week, how would you spend the last day?
- If you woke up as the only person left on Earth, what would you do first?
Deep hypothetical questions
For later in the evening, when people are ready to think.
- If you could master one skill overnight, which would change your life most?
- If you could live anywhere for a year at no cost, where would you go?
- If you could give your younger self one skill, not advice, what would it be?
- If you could start a tradition the whole world followed, what would it be?
- If you could change one thing about how people spend their weekends, what would it be?
- If you had to live by a single rule for the rest of your life, which rule would you pick?
- If you could talk for an hour with any version of yourself, which age would you pick?
- If you could know one thing about your future, what would you want to know?
- If you could guarantee one thing for the people you love, what would it be?
- If you could learn the honest answer to any one question, what would you ask?
- If you could only keep one memory, which would you choose?
- If you were remembered for one sentence, what would you want it to say?
- If you could be the best in the world at something but nobody could ever find out, would it be worth it?
- If you could live your life again knowing what you know now, would you?
- If you could watch your life from the outside for one day, what do you think would surprise you?
Want everyone answering on their own phone?
Table Party’s Never Have I Ever deals cards to every phone and keeps answers secret until everyone has guessed. It suits the same kind of table.
Free, on everyone’s phone. The host picks the deck in the lobby.
How to play hypotheticals with a group
- Pick a reader. They read one question out and give everyone ten seconds to think before anyone answers.
- Go round the group. Each person answers in a sentence or two, and the reader answers last so they don’t steer anyone.
- Allow one follow-up per answer. “Why that one?” or “What would go wrong?” is usually where the best part is.
- Pass the reading to the next person and choose a new section whenever the mood changes.
- For a game with a score, try Never Have I Ever on Table Party: everyone answers in secret on their own phone, then guesses how many people went the same way.

About hypothetical questions
A hypothetical question drops you into a situation that will never happen and asks what you would do. The answer says more about a person than a straight question would, because nobody has a rehearsed reply to “If you could pause time but aged while it was paused”.
The good ones carry a cost. A power with a catch, a prize with a condition or a dilemma with no clean exit makes people think out loud, and that is where the stories come from. They work for two people on a walk and just as well for a table of ten.
Tips for a better round
Hold the catch to the rules
When someone tries to wriggle out of the catch, hold them to it, because the catch is what makes the question worth asking.
Start light, end deep
Open with the funny or magical sections, and save the deep ones for later in the evening when people have warmed up.
Answer quickly first
Ask for a gut answer, then let people change their mind after hearing the others, which usually starts the real argument.
Swap sections often
Five questions from one section is plenty, so jump to another chip before the answers start sounding alike.
Common questions about hypotheticals
What is a hypothetical question?
It is a question about a situation that is not real, usually starting “What would you do if…” or “If you could…”. The person answering has to imagine it and choose, which shows how they think.
What makes a good hypothetical question?
A real choice. If every answer is the same, the question is too easy. Add a cost, a limit or a condition, like a power that only works on Tuesdays, and people start reasoning out loud.
How are hypothetical questions different from would you rather?
Would you rather gives two fixed options. A hypothetical gives a situation and leaves the answer open, so people can say anything, which makes for longer and more surprising answers.
How many people can play?
Two people can trade questions on a walk or a drive. With more than eight, ask for quick answers round the room and let two or three people explain theirs in full.
Are these hypothetical questions suitable for work?
Yes. Every question here is clean and none ask about money troubles, looks or anything painful. The funny, powers and everyday sections suit a team meeting best.
Can you play hypotheticals over a video call?
Yes. The reader shares one question, everyone types a one-line answer in the chat, and all send at once. Then each person explains theirs.